FootyChatter.com

Pep Guardiola spent £84m on Marc Guehi and Antoine Semenyo in the winter transfer window Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola said he was "a little bit grumpy" when asked about the club's January transfer business. Rather than concentrate on City being the biggest spenders for the second consecutive winter window, he preferred to focus on net spend. "In net spend the last five years we are seventh, " Guardiola insisted. It appeared to be targeted at critics of his team's performances this season. The Spanish manager seemed to be arguing that others have been spending more money to catch up. "They are facts, " Guardiola added. "Good luck to the six teams who are in front of us for net spend for the last five years. " Figures from Footballtransfers. com show City are sixth, not seventh, with a net spend of £324. 7m. But let's be fair to Guardiola. He is effectively correct. Nottingham Forest (£323m) pretty much have the same net spend despite being in the Championship for the first season of the calculation. But is it as straightforward as this for City? There are two ways of looking at things. Yes, City are not the biggest net spenders. But the data also shows they have spent the second most on players over this period. Chelsea have spent the most (£1. 57bn) to try to catch up with the likes of Manchester City. They have sold the most, too, with £862m worth of talent. Guardiola comes second on both: £962. 3m spent with £637. 6m brought in from sales. This underlines how City have been incredibly adept at bringing through players from their academy and selling them for high transfer fees. In fact around £280m has been recouped in this way in the last five years. Cole Palmer moved to Chelsea for £40. 9m. James Mc Atee was signed by Forest in a £22. 2m deal. Taylor Harwood-Bellis switched to Southampton for £20m. Between them they made six Premier League starts for City, yet all three appear as pure profit as club-trained players. This is not a criticism, though. It is exactly how an academy should operate. If a player is not to the level of the first team, or has limited opportunities, then they should be sold. Rinse and repeat the process as the years pass. But it could be construed as creating a slightly misleading picture in terms of net spend on the first team. Chelsea have the same kind of model so it should be no surprise that their finances are along similar lines. It is just to slightly different levels. Manchester United have the worst of all worlds: a high spend, a low return in transfers and disappointing results on the pitch. The Red Devils are third in spending (£920. 9m) but they have not come close to utilising the value of their academy, with player sales of just £246. 6m. That places them second in net spend (£674. 3m). This could also be said of Arsenal, who are third in net spend (£610. 1m) but they have the lowest outgoing sales of the top clubs - just £184. 2m. But of course the Gunners sit clear at the top of the Premier League. Their incoming transfer business of £743. 9m has been more effective than Manchester United's. Has the January transfer window always felt flat? The talented playmaker no-one seems to want Grade A*? Grade F? Rate your club's transfer window after deadline day Guardiola mentioned five years, but what happens if we take a longer term view over the last decade? It paints a very similar picture in spending on players. Chelsea (£2. 35bn) have spent the most, ahead of City (£1. 82m) and Manchester United (£1. 62bn). When we look at net spend the comparison gets worse for Manchester United, who have the highest net spend (£1. 18bn). Chelsea are in second (£993m), with Arsenal in third (£893. 3m) and City (£890m) marginally behind in fourth. On player sales only Chelsea (£1. 36bn) have brought in more money than City (£934. 6m). Arsenal are again the worst performers on sales (£418. 1m) ahead of Manchester United (£439m). You can see why Guardiola would feel aggrieved. Over the last five and 10 years his team have consistently not been close to the top of the net spend table. But when you are the only top club to be spending serious money in the January transfer window, it is a tough argument to win. Find all the latest football transfers on our dedicated page Comments can not be loaded To load Comments you need to enable Java Script in your browser The F1, football and NFL figures who kept Epstein links after conviction A 'special' snooker player who became a TV star - John Virgo obituary Is Guardiola right about Man City's lower net spend? A Welsh town finds itself in the middle of a drug smuggling ring One of the biggest scandals in the history of ice-skating A socially awkward man falls into the world of 'peak male excellence' Reece Parkinson discusses the reality of running with a chronic illness A 'special' snooker player who became a TV star - John Virgo obituary Who won the WSL transfer window? Rate each club's deals Is the evil empire back? How the Patriots rebuilt a broken dynasty 'Years in the making' - are Arsenal ready to shed 'nearly-men' tag? What impact might 'unprecedented' Six Nations schedule have? 'Don't be afraid of being different, it's your superpower' In Pictures: Sporting photos of the week Is the Australian Open still the 'Happy Slam'? Just seven signings - the Premier League's quiet deadline day 'Strong and smart' - Liverpool's £60m man, who can 'become like Van Dijk' Curling starts on Wednesday - two days before opening ceremony All the done deals on deadline day in one place Will Seahawks stop Patriots' record bid? Lowdown on Super Bowl 2026 Six Nations preview & BBC pundit predictions 'Complacent and lost control' - Man City's second-half problem Happy tennis, serious name - how history-maker Alcaraz clinched career Slam What's gone wrong for Chelsea in WSL and is Bompastor still right coach? Why 2026 could be GB's most successful Winter Olympics The most powerful woman in football - meet game's first female super agent Nine siblings and a dog called Zoomer - Wirtz in his own words Copyright © 2026 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.